Listen to this article

What lies inside the universe beyond stars and galaxies? Explore the mystery of consciousness, qualia, and why science cannot fully explain subjective human experience.

There is a fact about the universe that every scientific theory to date has failed to explain, and that most scientific theories do not even attempt to explain: that there is something it is like to be a conscious creature. When you see red, there is a qualitative character to that experience — a redness to the red — that is not captured by any description of the wavelengths of light, the firing of retinal cells, or the activation of visual cortex regions. When you feel pain, there is a felt quality — a hurting — that is not captured by any account of nociceptor activation or c-fibre discharge.

These qualitative, felt dimensions of experience — what philosophers call qualia — are not merely difficult to explain in physical terms. They are, as the philosopher David Chalmers argued in his formulation of the hard problem of consciousness, in principle resistant to the kind of explanation that works everywhere else in science.

The distinction Chalmers draws is between the easy problems and the hard problem of consciousness. The easy problems — not genuinely easy, but tractable in principle — concern the functional and behavioural capacities associated with consciousness: the ability to discriminate stimuli, integrate information, report mental states, focus attention, control behaviour.

These are hard scientific problems, but they are problems that can in principle be solved by identifying the neural mechanisms that implement the relevant functions. The hard problem is different in kind: it is the problem of explaining why any of these functional processes are accompanied by subjective experience at all — why there is something it is like to undergo them, rather than all the same processing occurring in the dark, without any inner life. The hard problem does not ask what the brain does. It asks why the brain’s doing it feels like anything.

The philosopher Thomas Nagel posed the problem with characteristic economy in his 1974 paper What Is It Like to Be a Bat? Bats navigate by echolocation — a perceptual system so different from human vision that we cannot, Nagel argued, form any genuine conception of what bat experience is like from the inside. We can know everything about the neurophysiology of bat echolocation and still not know what it is like to be a bat. This asymmetry between third-person scientific knowledge and first-person experiential knowledge is not a temporary gap to be closed by better neuroscience.

It is a structural feature of the difference between objective and subjective points of view — and it suggests that a complete science of consciousness, if such a thing is possible, will require conceptual resources that current science does not possess.

The materialist response — that consciousness is identical to, or constituted by, or emergent from physical processes in the brain — comes in several forms, each with distinctive difficulties. Type identity theory holds that mental states just are brain states — that pain is identical to c-fibre firing in the same way that water is identical to H2O.

The difficulty is that this seems to get the modal facts wrong: water is necessarily H2O, but pain does not seem to be necessarily identical to any particular physical state, since we can coherently imagine creatures in the same pain state with different physical implementations. Functionalism responds by identifying mental states with functional roles rather than physical realisations — pain is whatever state is caused by tissue damage and causes avoidance behaviour, regardless of its physical substrate. The difficulty is that functionalism seems to leave out the qualitative feel: a system that plays the functional role of pain but feels nothing would, by functionalist lights, be in pain — which seems wrong.

The philosopher Frank Jackson crystallised the explanatory gap in his knowledge argument — the Mary’s Room thought experiment. Mary is a brilliant neuroscientist who has spent her entire life in a black-and-white room, learning everything there is to know about the physics and neuroscience of colour vision.

When she leaves the room and sees red for the first time, does she learn something new? Jackson argued that she does — she learns what it is like to see red — and that this new knowledge reveals that her complete physical knowledge of colour vision was incomplete: it left out the qualitative character of colour experience. If this is right, then physicalism — the thesis that the physical facts about the world are all the facts — is false.

The panpsychist response — associated with philosophers including Galen Strawson and Philip Goff — takes the hard problem seriously by denying that consciousness is an emergent property of complex physical organisation. If consciousness cannot be derived from purely physical description, perhaps consciousness is itself a fundamental feature of reality — present, in some form, at every level of organisation.

Electrons do not have rich inner lives, on this view, but they have some form of proto-experiential property that combines, in complex physical systems, to produce the rich consciousness of humans and other animals. Panpsychism avoids the hard problem by dissolving the gap between matter and mind at the fundamental level, but at the cost of the combination problem: it is unclear how simple proto-experiential properties combine to produce the unified, complex consciousness that characterises human experience.

The neuroscientist Giulio Tononi’s integrated information theory offers a more mathematically precise approach: consciousness is identical to integrated information — a measure, denoted phi, of the degree to which a system generates more information as a whole than the sum of its parts. High phi corresponds to high consciousness; zero phi corresponds to no consciousness.

The theory makes precise, potentially empirically testable predictions about which systems are conscious and to what degree. Its critics argue that it produces counterintuitive results — attributing high consciousness to certain simple feedback systems and low consciousness to systems whose behavioural sophistication suggests otherwise — and that it has not solved the hard problem so much as redefined it: why should integrated information feel like anything?

The hard problem of consciousness matters beyond academic philosophy for the same reason that all foundational questions matter: because the answers shape what questions we think are worth asking and what kinds of explanation we accept as adequate. If consciousness is fully explicable in physical terms, then a science of mind is possible in the same sense that a science of chemistry is possible.

If it is not, then the project of a complete materialist science of reality faces a limit that is not merely technical but principled — a domain of fact that third-person methods, however refined, cannot in principle reach. The inside of the universe is not obviously accessible from the outside.

Share This Article, Choose Your Platform!

Leave A Comment