Listen to this article

Quantum mechanics is the most precisely confirmed scientific theory in history. Its predictions have been verified to eleven decimal places — a degree of accuracy unmatched by any other branch of science. It underlies the transistor, the laser, the MRI scanner, and the entire architecture of modern semiconductor technology. It is, by any measure of empirical success, the most successful theory human beings have ever produced.

It is also, as the physicist Richard Feynman remarked, a theory that nobody understands — not in the sense that its mathematics is intractable, which it is not, but in the sense that what the mathematics is describing, what is actually happening in the world that makes the predictions come out right, remains the subject of deep and unresolved disagreement among physicists and philosophers of science after more than a century of argument.

The source of the interpretive difficulty is the measurement problem. In the formalism of quantum mechanics, physical systems evolve according to the Schrodinger equation — a deterministic wave equation that describes the evolution of a quantum state, a superposition of all the possible values of a physical quantity, each with an associated amplitude.

The strange thing happens at measurement: when a physical quantity is measured, the system appears to jump discontinuously into one of the possible values, with probability proportional to the square of the amplitude. This jump — the collapse of the wave function — is not described by the Schrodinger equation. It is an additional postulate, added to make predictions match observations. The measurement problem is the problem of explaining what a measurement is, what causes the collapse, and why the quantum world of superpositions gives rise to the classical world of definite values that we observe.

The Copenhagen interpretation — the orthodox view associated with Niels Bohr and Werner Heisenberg — responded to the measurement problem by, in effect, refusing to answer it. The wave function, on this view, is not a description of physical reality but a tool for calculating the probabilities of measurement outcomes.

Questions about what is happening between measurements — about whether the electron ‘really has’ a definite position before it is measured — are, in Bohr’s formulation, meaningless. Physics describes what we can say about the world, not what the world is. The price of this pragmatic success is a radical restriction on the ambitions of scientific explanation: the Copenhagen interpretation tells us how to calculate but not what to believe about the physical world that the calculations describe.

The physicist Hugh Everett proposed a radically different resolution in his 1957 relative state formulation — what later became known as the many-worlds interpretation. Everett’s key move was to deny that there is anything special about measurement — to insist that the Schrodinger equation applies universally, including to measuring devices and observers. If the electron is in a superposition of spin-up and spin-down, and the measuring device interacts with it, then the combined system of electron and device is in a superposition — one branch containing a device registering spin-up, another containing a device registering spin-down. Both branches are real.

The observer, in interacting with the device, also branches — one version of the observer sees spin-up, another sees spin-down. There is no collapse, no privileged observer, no mysterious measurement process: only the universal, deterministic evolution of the wave function, giving rise to an ever-branching tree of parallel worlds.

David Bohm’s pilot wave theory — also called Bohmian mechanics — offered a third resolution by restoring the classical picture of particles with definite positions at all times, guided by a wave that evolves according to the Schrodinger equation. In Bohm’s theory, there is no measurement problem: particles always have definite values, and the appearance of quantum randomness reflects our ignorance of the precise initial conditions rather than any fundamental indeterminacy.

The pilot wave theory reproduces all the predictions of quantum mechanics exactly. Its critics object that it is nonlocal — the wave that guides a particle depends on what is happening to distant particles instantaneously — which seems to conflict with the spirit, if not the letter, of special relativity.

The philosopher of science Tim Maudlin has argued that the disagreement among interpretations of quantum mechanics is not merely a matter of taste or metaphysical preference but a genuine scientific question — about what the physical world is actually like — and that the widespread attitude of dismissing it as merely philosophical is itself a philosophical position, and a bad one.

The Copenhagen refusal to say what is happening between measurements is not neutral: it is a commitment to an anti-realist view of scientific theories — the view that theories are instruments for prediction rather than descriptions of reality. This is a substantive philosophical position that should be argued for rather than assumed, and that conflicts with how physicists treat their theories in every other domain.

The physicist and philosopher Carlo Rovelli’s relational interpretation offers a more recent resolution: quantum states are not descriptions of absolute physical reality but descriptions of the state of a system relative to a given observer or measuring device. There is no observer-independent quantum state; what a system is doing is always relative to something else.

This interpretation dissolves the measurement problem by denying that there is a single fact of the matter about what a quantum system is doing independent of its relations to other systems — a position with affinities to both Copenhagen pragmatism and the relational metaphysics of thinkers like Leibniz.

What the interpretive debate about quantum mechanics ultimately reveals is a tension that runs through the philosophy of science more generally: the tension between the instrumentalist view that scientific theories are tools for predicting observations and the realist view that they are descriptions of what the world is actually like.

Quantum mechanics has made this tension unavoidable because it is a theory of extraordinary predictive power whose physical meaning cannot be read directly off its formalism. It forces the question that instrumentalism tries to avoid: if we are not trying to find out what the world is like, what exactly are we doing when we do science? The theory that nobody understands has, in this sense, done more for the philosophy of science than any theory that everyone thought they understood.

Share This Article, Choose Your Platform!

Leave A Comment